If you’re looking to collect the best of the best cards in MLB The Show 21’s Diamond Dynasty game mode you’re going to need an almost impossible amount of luck. That, or a whole lot of Stubs to purchase the card on the Community Market. In this guide, we’ll list all available diamond cards in Diamond Dynasty (aka the Diamond Club).
Keep in mind that the prices we list for these cards is just to give you an idea as to how much a complete set will cost. We used the Buy it Now price which frequently isn’t the best available deal. Make sure to hunt for the cheapest card you can find. These prices were fetched on April 21, 2021.
If you wanted to purchase every single diamond card in the game it would set you back 4,100,000 Stubbs. While value depends on which Stubbs bundle you purchase, we generally equate 25,000 Stubbs to $20 for easy math. If you were to purchase all of these right now with the $20 bundle it would cost you $3,300. If you purchased the biggest bundle of 150,000 Stubbs for $100, you could decrease the cost to $2,700.
42 Series Set Diamond Cards
- Frank Thomas (88) – 32,000 Stubs
- Ken Griffey Jr. (88) – 35,000 Stubs
- Hank Aaron (88) – 28,000 Stubs
- Bob Gibson (88) – 34,000 Stubs
- Jackie Robinson (88) – 34,000 Stubs
- Willie Mays (88) – 33,000 Stubs
- Cal Ripken Jr. (88) – 34,000 Stubs
- Pedro Martinez (88) – 32,000 Stubs
- Babe Ruth (88) – 33,000 Stubs
- Mariano Rivera (88) – 33,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 328,000 Stubs ($328)
Second Half Set Diamond Cards
- Mike Schmidt (92) – 81,000 Stubs
- Nolan Ryan (92) – 218,000 Stubs
- Jorge Soler (91) – 62,000 Stubs
- Felix Hernandez (91) – 44,000 Stubs
- Mike Piazza (91) – 80,000 Stubs
- John Smoltz (85) – 18,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 503,000 Stubs ($400)
All-Star Set Diamond Cards
- Tom Seaver (92) – 72,000 Stubs
- Miguel Cabrera (92) – 105,000 Stubs
- Ryne Sandberg (92) – 150,000 Stubs
- Prince Fielder (92) – 240,000 Stubs
- Billy Wagner (91) – 87,000 Stubs
- Jason Kendall (87) – 20,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 674,000 Stubs ($540)
Breakout Set Diamond Cards
- Tino Martinez (87) – 18,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 18,000 Stubs ($14)
Future Stars Set Diamond Cards
- Nomar Mazara (85) – 13,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 13,000 Stubs ($10)
Live Set Diamond Cards
- Mike Trout (95) – 350,000 Stubs
- Mookie Betts (92) – 92,000 Stubs
- Jacob deGrom (91) – 108,000 Stubs
- Nolan Arenado (90) – 99,000 Stubs
- Cody Bellinger (90) – 94,000 Stubs
- Gerrit Cole (90) – 78,000 Stubs
- Ronald Acuna Jr. (90) – 140,000 Stubs
- Aaron Judge (89) – 48,000 Stubs
- Freddie Freeman (89) – 47,000 Stubs
- Christian Yelich (88) – 50,000 Stubs
- Chris Sale (88) – 41,000 Stubs
- Justin Verlander (88) – 27,000 Stubs
- Shane Bieber (88) – 30,000 Stubs
- Max Scherzer (88) – 29,000 Stubs
- Fernando Tatis Jr. (88) – 77,000 Stubs
- Manny Machado (88) – 37,000 Stubs
- Josh Hader (87) – 27,000 Stubs
- Francisco Lindor (87) – 43,000 Stubs
- Anthony Rendon (87) – 22,000 Stubs
- Bryce Harper (87) – 38,000 Stubs
- Stephen Strasburg (87) – 22,000 Stubs
- Jose Ramirez (87) – 34,000 Stubs
- Juan Soto (87) – 54,000 Stubs
- Trevor Story (87) – 39,000 Stubs
- Clayton Kershaw (87) – 23,000 Stubs
- Nick Anderson (87) – 25,000 Stubs
- Devin Williams (86) – 22,000 Stubs
- Alex Bregman (86) – 21,000 Stubs
- J.T. Realmuto (86) – 22,000 Stubs
- Trevor Bauer (86) – 22,000 Stubs
- Corey Seager (86) – 33,000 Stubs
- D.J. LeMahieu (86) – 25,000 Stubs
- Kirby Yates (85) – 16,000 Stubs
- Aaron Nola (85) – 13,000 Stubs
- Liam Hendricks (85) – 18,000 Stubs
- Jose Abreu (85) – 18,000 Stubs
- Matt Chapman (85) – 17,000 Stubs
- Walker Buehler (85) – 17,000 Stubs
- Aroldis Chapman (85) – 32,000 Stubs
- Yu Darvish (85) – 18,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 2,000,000 Stubs ($1,600)
Milestone Set Diamond Cards
- Kenny Lofton (93) – 82,000 Stubs
- Jeurys Familia (90) – 45,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 127,000 Stubs ($100)
Postseason Set Diamond Cards
- Lou Brock (92) – 95,000 Stubs
- Josh Donaldson (91) – 34,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 129,000 Stubs ($100)
Prospect Set Diamond Cards
- Wander Franco (91) – 45,000 Stubs
- C.J. Abrams (90) – 34,000 Stubs
- Jasson Dominguez (86) – 18,000 Stubs
- Matthew Liberatore (86) – 18,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 115,000 Stubs ($90)
Rookie Set Diamond Cards
- Fernando Valenzuela (93) – 70,000 Stubs
- Kenley Kansen (87) – 19,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 89,000 Stubs ($70)
Topps Now Set Diamond Cards
- Ryan McMahon (86) – 15,000 Stubs
- Joe Musgrove (86) – 14,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 29,000 Stubs ($20)
Veteran Set Diamond Cards
- Vladimir Guerrero (92) – 75,000 Stubs
- Roberto Clemente (85) – 6,000 Stubs
Total Cost: About 81,000 Stubs ($65)
